From the BlogSubscribe Now

Ye islam nahi hay

We have all been brought up by our elders to not question men of our faith, some of us were given the leverage to do so and thus developed a higher level of understanding as to what Islam is and what it actually entails. Others however were taught dogmatically and rigidly and thus for them to question someone speaking from a pulpit with a long beard is almost akin to committing social murder.

Perhaps this is the core difference between the masses and the moderate elite of Pakistan the difference in which they have been taught Islam. Perhaps this is why a Karachiite is not able to accept the Islam being propagated by the Taliban while someone in Swat just bows their head and nods. This has to be so because the million strong throng of men witnessed at the Muslim Khans rally call could not be there only because of his good will. Nay they looked like they were ready to do it all for him and those were ordinary residents of Swat who no doubt are convinced that the Taliban are their saviors.

However we as a society cannot function if the moderates among us are wiped out of existence or lashed for speaking their minds. We have a task, which is to enlighten and educate the conservatives and to point out to them the vivid differences between the Prophet Muhammad’s implemented Shariah and the one being implemented by the Taliban. Obviously we each have a different interpretation of Islam and thus have to find and consult ulema who can help guide us as to where we are headed with our reasoning.

For this purpose I had the good fortune of coming in contact with Dr Khalid Zaheer an enlightened scholar of Islam who helped clear out a lot of my thoughts regarding the following three burning questions.

1. Where in our religion is beheading allowed and against what crime? How is it that the taliban are beheading people for crimes like spying?

KZ :Islam allows taking the life of another human for two — and only — reasons: If the individual is guilty of killing another human or he is, worse still, guilty of creating mischief on earth, which means he has caused the life, wealth, or honour of others to be in peril because of his misdeeds. In the latter case, such criminals are allowed to be sometimes killed in a merciless manner, if the severity of the crime so demands. If an individual kills another human for any reasons other than these two, he will be held guilty of killing the entire mankind. (Qur’an; 5:32)

Taliban are killing people for spying because they find some mentions of similar incidents of killing in the hadith. What they fail to understand is the fact that the cases mentioned in the hadith have to do with the times of the messenger alone. The Quran clarifies unmistakably the fact that the people who deny God’s messengers during their lifetime are to be subjected to divine punishments. One form divine punishments can take is through the might of the companions of the prophet. The Quran clarifies that during the prophet’s life, it was this kind of punishment that was inflicted on the enemies of Islam. It has nothing to do with any other times.

Taliban and the likes do not acknowledge that reality. They are people who cannot be talked to. Therefore the damage that has been done cannot, unfortunately, be undone by any amount of efforts.


2. Religiously speaking is it right to demand of women not to venture out of their home for work or recreation?

KZ :There is no reason why women can be prevented from stepping out of their homes. Again, during the lifetime of the prophet, his wives were asked not to step out of their homes unnecessarily, because there were hypocrites and Jews who wanted to scandalize the family of the prophet, alaihissalaam. Quran is clear in this matter too. Taliban generalize those verses and the ahadith related to them even though there are many others that clarify the real understanding.

3. Does Islam allow for annexation of land through religion, if we recall the Muslims of mecca won many battles and ruled many countries during their time, can the Taliban then capture Pakistan as their right to spread Islam?

KZ: No, Muslims can’t do it now. What happened in the first generation of Muslims again had to do with God’s laws for the messengers.

You will find that many modern-day problems are linked with two issues: Muslims i) not willing to alter their views and as a consequence ii) not understanding the clear mention of the law regarding the messengers in the Quran.


In short my friends, this is hardly the Islam brought by the Quran and taught by the Prophet through his teachings the sunnah, this is a very rigid very cruel subversion of it based on Wahabiasm and Talibanism mixed with just the added flavor of militancy to make it suitable to the needs of this section of our country. We must learn the difference and I hope this writeup will go a few steps in that direction.

Finally they speak the truth

Hoisting the red flag amid green shadows

By : Farooq Tariq


The historic and victorious lawyer’s movement was a rainbow of various political colour. One could see all sorts of political trends trying to give their colors to lawyer’s movement. There were greens like Jamaat-I Islami and Muslim League Nawaz, reds like Labour Party and National Workers Party. There was tri-color Pakistan Peoples Party. Similarly, Tehreek Insaaf and some of the nationalist parties would join with their multi-coloured flags. Finally, the victory of the lawyer’s movement was not seen as victory for a particular colour. Thus the victory brought partial successes for everybody but not a decisive one for anybody.

Now a new movement is building up. It is a peasant movement that going on for nine long years. And its colour is red.

On 17 April, thousands of peasants were flying red flags amid shadows of green-fields. But even importantly, during a period when politics has gone ‘green’. Unlike West, the colour green in Pakistan signifies right-wing and Islamists.

dsc01907

At Okara Military Farms, when over 20,000 peasants and tenants gathered on April 17, it was the biggest red-dominated event in last three decades (police estimated 15,000). The event was organized by Anjaman Mozareen Punjab (AMP). The demand was simple: ”Give us the land we are cultivating for the last 100 years”.

They want to have ownership rights for 68000 acres of land, occupied by Military Farms management though the owner of the land is Punjab government.

Despite repeated assurances and promises by successive governments for last 61 years, the issue is still to be resolved. On April 17 that also was International Day of Peasants, the promise made by the late Benazir Bhutto, whose party rules Pakistan, and Nawaz Sharif, whose party rules Punjab province, were discussed at the tent-city erected outside of Chack 4/4L at Okara Military Farms.

It was a scene beyond description. Peasants, clad in their traditional dresses, were reaching the venue brimming with emotions. They were dancing to Dhool-beats. The peasant leaders atop others shoulders, were taken to the platform. There were a lot of stalls set up especially for the event. A group was dressed all red. There were over three thousands peasant women. Nobody wearing any burqa, hijab or niqab. They were all sitting together and no so-called religious restrictions were accepted by them. Religious harmony was reflected by the fact that Muslim and Christian were attending and organizing the event together.

This was the fifth peasant convention in last three months. Over 30,000 peasants participated in these conventions in different parts of Punjab, demanding the land ownership. Three peasants were killed during this round of struggle and 27 injured when the gangsters of the military generals and other top officers opened fire on the peasants at Chack 28/RB at Kulyana Military Estate. The peasants responded by occupying the land leased to top military officers and distributing among the families of martyrs and injured ones. The top military officers wanted to crush   this uprising. They choose a wrong time and their estimation of the consequences of this brutal attack brought results just the opposite of their expectations. This incident has strengthened the movement and did not weaken it as they were hoping for.

dsc017911

This new round of struggle was started in the beginning of 2009 by reorganizing the AMP. The decision to form village-level committees proved absolutely correct. The suggestion to continue with the women in the lead was another fact that enthused the movement.

The April 17 convention was addressed by the local leaders of AMP, Labour Party Pakistan and representatives of lawyer’s movement. The local leadership of Pakistan Peoples Party also turned up, including the provincial labour minister. The labour minister must have seen the live coverage of the convention aired by GEO, Dunia, ARY and Dawn news channels. He must have been eager to show his face to the public. Unfortunate for him as when he arrived, the electronic media had left. He was not invited by the organizers. The presence of these PPP leaders at the convention shows the power of the movement where the leaders of bourgeois parties are eager to come to express hypocratic solidarity.

The speakers from AMP set dead line for the acceptance of their demand. The deadline announced was 21 May 2009, granting nearly 5 weeks to the government to act. These leaders declared that the long march would start from Multan and reach Lahore to Gherao the Chief Minister’s secretariat. The AMP leaders are serious in their warning of a long march. They have marched several times during Musharaf dictatorship. They faced brutal treatment at the hands of the dictator’s police but refused to budge. Seven tenants were killed during that repression, many more injured, arrested and implicated in fake cases. All these repressive measures could not disillusion the movement.

The historic gathering on 17 April is not just a one time event. It is continuation of the struggle launched in year 2000. Several large scale mass meetings have been organized in the last nine years but this one was the largest so for. It seems that all the peasants of the area were there. Several small scale farms that were not part of the movement decided yesterday to be part of the movement after what they say a peasant uprising on the making. It will influence all the peasants in Punjab particularly who are in the grip of feudal system and are eager to find a way out.

The gathering had nothing to do with the tactics used by the parties of the rich and feudal. These parties provide transport, food and some pocket money to most of the participants to have “mass” meetings. Here the peasants came on their tractors-trollies, motorcycles and cycles, by foot and in buses they rented after collecting the funds among themselves. There were peasants from Lahore, Sarghoda, and Faisalabad, Khanewal, Sahiwal, Pakpattan and Qasur district. There was not a single participant of this gathering that was brought directly by the organizers from other districts paying for their transport. There were plenty of small scale shops out side the venue where the peasants were buying their food.

One aspect of the convention was the sale of Weekly Mazdoor Jeddojuhd (www.jeddojuhd.com). 440 copies sold at the convention showing the respect that the paper has build by providing its full cooperation to this movement.

The color of the flag of the AMP is red with their traditional image of plough. There were hundreds of red flags. Rafiq Saraf from Checha Watni, a veteran left leader in his eighties remarked that he could die in peace now. “I have never seen so many red flags in any event. I am sick and tired of seeing green flags of the conservatives and Islamic parties all over. It is good to see the red flag amid green shadows” he remarked.

A new movement is in the making. This time it is led by the progressive forces. It is building an alternative politics also. It is the most powerful movement of the progressive forces after long time in Pakistan. A class-based movement is spreading. It is not an abstract movement. It is very clear in its aims and objectives. It is not just demanding land for the tenants but challenging the hegemony of the politics of the rich. It is led by the peasants themselves. It is not any outsider that is making inroads in the movement. The leadership of AMP, many of them members of Labour Party, is committed to build the movement with a wider perspectives and linking it to end the feudal and capitalist system while introducing the superiority of Socialist ideas in practice.

It is movement that must be supported by all those who want a progressive Pakistan with the empowerment of the most down trodden strata of society. It is time to shed all the confusions and time to take a side. We have taken a side since 2000; it is your turn now.

Operation restarts in swat

Finally after much hue and cry raised by the entire countries moderate and civil structure as well as some timely concern shown by political parties the army has woken up and started an operation against the militants in the lower dir valley area of Swat.

This operation was started yesterday and immediately helicopter gunships and bombing missions through them have brought about some measure of success. So much for all the Taliban apologists who were claiming that “the force of change” cannot be routed.

The problem is that we as a nation neither want this change being forced upon us neither can we afford it in our precarious position in the international arena. The adverse result of which will be in full bloom if the Taliban ever take over. I daresay we would be invaded by Nato forces within the week to secure our nuclear weapons if a “takeover” threat ever materializes on solid evidence. Now one wonders if whether this is indeed the mission of these Talibs? Rather than “sharia imposition”. I say this as the source of financing and backing for these Talibs seems to be very dubious and maybe foreign.

The Taliban’s misadventure of a “preaching” mission in the buner sector and their various contradictory statements to the peace accord have in the least shown that even though their spokesman claims full backing, he has no idea of how to control the hordes currently under his sway, who want nothing short of an advance into other areas of Pakistan on their holy mission.

The government of Pakistan needs to realize this before it is too late. The army needs to route these invaders once and for all and it can, for their physical strength is limited to a few thousand. In fact a friend in khaki just told me last week that it is a matter of 2 battalions to take these people out of their misery. We as a people must also realize that once and for all we have to become united on this issue there is no middle ground here.

I wonder why they are being then negotiated with time and again? Have we not realized as a nation that this organization is like a hydra, talk peace with one head and the other suicide bombs you out of existance.

Vote for Faraz anwar @ guitar idol 09

Pakistan is being represented at Guitar Idol 09, the biggest competition for rock guitarists by Faraz anwar of Mizrab band.

He is brilliant on the axe and has reached the finals of this competition. I want each and every reader of this blog to vote for this gem of a guitarist from Pakistan!!

Vote by clicking on the url below and then registering before proceeding to cast your vote. Lets support this Pakistani in his quest for recognition internationally!!!

VOTE FOR FARAZ ANWAR

If he wins we win!!!!

An open letter to the president of pakistan

By Barrister Ali.K Chisti

My Dear President,
I hope you are well..? I see you on the television every day with a wide smile and Mash’Allah you look younger than ever each passing day.

My Dear President, I will come straight to the point, I am concerned as much as you are about the SWAT Deal and the Talibanization of Pakistan – I also understand that you are one of the direct victims of these butchers who call themselves Talibans……and the recent deal by ANP Legislators – apparently your coalition partners with Talibans has actually shocked and depressed us all – especially back in Southern Pakistan….

It is the first time in the history of mankind that a national legislature has conceded, without being under coercion, the state’s writ over a part of the country. Practically, Pakistan had already surrendered its writ over Swat, the NWFP and the FATA. With the National Assembly of Pakistan passing this resolution, the de facto partition is now de jure, legal. It appears to be limited to the Malakand Division. However, it is a legal precedent to include other divisions at later dates. Bit by bit, the whole de facto partition of Pakistan would be de jure.

It is more than a Greek tragedy, President. The elected representatives of the people of Pakistan partitioning the country without a referendum to know if their constituents had really wanted to partition their homeland. It is the ultimate treachery. The betrayal of the nation by its elected representatives – Brutes, Brutes!

The National Assembly of Pakistan did not even bother to debate over this monumental issue.

Monday, April 13, 2009, is a black day in the history of Pakistan. What makes it worse is that the people of Pakistan do not appear to know it. It appears awareness comes to those only, who seek it.

We appeared to have signed a deal with the murderers of this nation’s soldiers and innocents. They will never forgive us !

I ask my Dear President, as to why sign such a deal when we have Objective Resolutions as part of our Constitution? The resolution states that “sovereignty over the entire universe belongs to God Almighty alone and the authority which He has delegated to the State of Pakistan through its people for being exercised within the limits prescribed by Him is a sacred trust”. Thus it was ordained that no legislation could be adopted in Pakistan which was against the tenets of Islam. Everything had to stay within the “limits prescribed by Him”. The resolution was presented to the assembly by the first Prime Minister of the newly created republic of Pakistan Nawab Liaquat Ali Khan – so why this new Sharia Deal..?

Dear President, I also know that it was not the first time that the National Assembly of Pakistan brought grief to the people. The parliament in the 50s agreed to a parity rule for East Pakistan causing a majority province to be at par with all minority provinces combined in one-unit. Though it is not the parliamentarians alone. Things did things got to the point after the army was beaten/unwilling to fight, in Swat ? Is that why provincial government was forced to have a truce with the enemy. Why can’t anyone in the Government for-heaven sakes, reply to our questions honestly?

And what kind of Shariat will Sufi Mohammad will bring? Tehrik-i-Nifaz-i-Shariat-i-Muhammadi’s Chief Sufi Mohammad gave out statements that the militants accused of brutal killings would not be prosecuted under Islamic Law? And that Sufi Muhammad and Fazalluah or any of the members of the Tehrik-i-Nifaz-i-Shariat-i-Muhammadi will not be asked to stand up for trail in front of Qazi’s? What kind of self-tailored Shariat is this My President?

And now after you signed the Presidential Order’s Sufi Mohammad the self-proclaimed leader of Talibans who considers Baitullah Masud the murderer of your wife and thousands of Pakistanis as his role-model considers the whole of Parliament which voted for the deal as NOT ISLAMIC and the Judiciary – Devil’s Work!

My Dear President, Kindly review your decision – think for the stability of Pakistan in the long run and revoke this deal which is bound to fail – show some courage and force our Army of the so-called Marshall Race to go into SWAT and stop these barbarians, Talibans who close girl’s schools, murder innocents and flog girls! They are Terrorists and a threat to World Peace – Deals with them will only make them strong….

Your One Signature To Revoke This Deal Could Save This Country, Do It Before It’s Too Late………!!!!

Aus-Pak Chappal cup

600-dubai_sports_city_cricket_stadium_ring_of_fire_lights_up_night_sky_jpgThings could not have been better for Pakistan’s cricket and PCB right now. First off they entered into contract to play at a neutral venue in Dubai at a brand spanking new purpose built stadium and to top it all off they got Australia to play the first series with them there.

Although the Aussies came without Lee or Ponting or for that matter Hussey they still represented a more than difficult threat for a team which had not played against a major international side in some time.

So you can imagine this fans surprise when Pakistan ran all over them, Aussies chose to bat and then were bewildered by all types of crazy spin from Afridi as well as Saeed Ajmal with his doosras. To me Saeed Ajmal looks like a Saqlain clone but Afridi has certainly benefited from Abdul Qadirs advice and was ripping it quite well. At one point the Aussies were cruising and then within the space of 23 runs 7 wickets fell leaving them tottering at 168 all out.

Although Pak relaxed a bit too much for my taste during their chase and gave up some seemingly silly wickets, but Misbah and Akmal guided us to victory in the end. Akmal’s catching too seems to have greatly improved. All in all it was a glimmer of hope for all us fans of green, we proved to ourselves once again that our team can still do it, even if they do it with a few bumbles and fumbles.

Still the series is 5 matches long and this was only the first, I look forward to the Aussies bringing the fight to Pakistan and this being a great tourney in all. As it is the IPL is boring as hell and we here in Karachi are starving for some good Pak cricket :)

Go Pak!! I want a big yellar grave in the sands of Dubai!!

Why are muslims suffering?

By Dr Khalid Zaheer

A tiny minority of Muslims has engaged itself in a war (jihad) against the West in general and against the US, Israel, and India in particular. What they are doing through their military adventurism is causing the entire Muslim ummah suffering at the hands of the Jihadis and, because of their misadventures, at the hands of the US and others as well.

The analysis of the situation done by the Jihadi Muslims is that there is a grand conspiracy of the Jews which has caused the entire West to go against Islam and Muslims. They believe that the only way to counter this trend is to undertake an open war against them. If Muslims join hands and fight against the US, Israel, and India, God Almighty would help them in annihilating these enemies of God, His messenger, and Muslims.

Most certainly, proper solution to a problem is based upon two components: the right analysis of the problem and a sincere effort at implementing the solution based on the analysis. In my opinion the analysis of these Muslims is seriously flawed. The truth is that the opposition of the US, Israel, and India against Muslims and their successful attempts to subjugate and cause serious damage to us is not the cause of our woes. Their successful military adventurism against us is in itself the result of another, bigger cause. It is God’s displeasure with Muslims that has allowed Americans, Israelis, and Indians to successfully launch their military campaign against us because God is allowing them to be succeed in their mission. It cannot be that despite the fact that He doesn’t want them to cause damage to us, we would still suffer.

What is happening to us is exactly what happened to the Children of Israel, the Muslims of the earlier times, in their history of two thousand years before the arrival of Prophet Muhammad, Allah’s mercy be on him. The Qur’an describes their suffering in these words:

“And we forewarned the Children of Israel in their Holy Book that ‘you will do mischief in the land twice through and you will become arrogant transgressors (and each time you will be punished).’

When the promise for the first of the two fore warnings came to be fulfilled, WE SENT AGAINST YOU OUR SERVANTS WITH MILITARY MIGHT: THEY RAMPAGED THROUGH YOUR HOMES TO CARRY OUT THE PUNISHMENT OF WHICH YOU WERE FOREWARNED. Then after this, we afforded you an opportunity to overpower them and helped you with wealth and sons and granted you more manpower. If you perform well you do so for your own benefit; but if you do evil, it would cause harm to your own selves.

Then, when the promise for your second forewarning came to be fulfilled, (WE SENT ANOTHER ARMY) TO DISFIGURE YOUR FACES AND TO ENTER YOUR TEMPLE AS THE FORMER HAD ENTERED IT BEFORE AND THEY UTTERLY DESTROYED ALL THAT THEY LAID THEIR HANDS ON.

Now your Lord may again be merciful to you; but if you repeat the same behavior, we will repeat the punishment, and in the hereafter, we have made hell a prison for such unbelievers.

Surely this Qur’an guides to the way that is perfectly straight and gives the good news to the believers who do good deeds that they shall have a magnificent reward, and at the same time it gives warnings to those who do not believe in the hereafter, that we have prepared for them a painful punishment.” (Qur’an; 17:4-10)

Indeed one of these two analyses of the situation could be correct: It’s either the lack of proper willingness, as the Jihadis say, in the majority of Muslims to fight against the US and its allies which is causing Muslims to be damned in this world or it is God’s decision to inflict His punishment on Muslims through “our servants with military might” which is causing Muslims to be in the state of complete disarray. One of the two possibilities could be correct. Both cannot be simultaneously correct unless one agrees with the proposition that God is displeased with Muslims because they were not undertaking Jihad against the non-Muslims, which is what the Qur’an is most certainly “not” suggesting. The Qur’an is warning the Children of Israel in the above-stated passage of dire consequences because they did mischief on the land twice and they become arrogant transgressors.

The fact that God is punishing us through non-Muslims is undeniable. The reason this has happened is not because we are not undertaking proper war against our enemies but because of our “mischief” and “arrogance”. In my opinion the following are some of the prominent misdeeds that have invited God’s punishment to be inflicted on Muslims:

i) As a nation Muslims are corrupt. Cheating, disregard of merit, and breaking of commitments are some of the crimes we are consistently committing. Exceptions apart, hypocrisy is the hallmark of the present-day Muslims.
ii) The present-day Muslims are extremely arrogant. Despite being morally corrupt, Muslims are dead sure that they will eventually succeed in the hereafter while all non-Muslims shall be doomed.
iii) The greatest evil in the present-day Muslims is that although they were expected to bring non-Muslims closer to Islam by their good acts and words, they have caused them to hate the religion of God by presenting a picture of it which cannot incline a decent human being to accept it as the religion of God. The Islam Muslims are presenting appears to be against every beautiful blessing God has created for humans in this life; it seems to suggest that the creator of this world is, God forbid, extremely unfair in that He will look at the religion of humans and not their intentions and deeds while deciding about their eternal fate; they have also caused great harm to the message of God by creating the impression that hating fellow humans to the extent of even killing them was a part of the expectation of God from his His devoted servants.

If these allegations against Muslims were correct, how can a sane non-Muslim come close to Islam? And if non-Muslims, who are equally God’s creation, have been drawn away from His religion by the misdeeds of Muslims, how can He be pleased with them? And if He is annoyed with Muslims, why should He not punish them?

If what I am claiming is correct, then the Jihadis are fighting a losing battle, because they are not fighting against the Americans, Israelis, or Indians; they are fighting against God’s decision. If they are really interested in bringing back the lost glory of Muslims, they should address the problems that are causing God to be displeased with them.

_____________________________________________

Dr Khalid Zaheer is the Director Education, Al-Mawrid, which is an NGO established to promote research and education on Islam. Prior to joining Al-Mawrid in September 2006, he was an Associate Professor of Islamic Studies and Ethics at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS). He has a teaching experience of more than 20 years. He can be reached @ www.khalidzaheer.com

A new horror

Not a day goes by without some sort of threat in Pakistan to its citizens. by these mysterious men we have come to know loosely as the Taliban.

We have as citizens of this country faced, murder, extortion, kidnapping for ransom, days without electricity and food shortages, we have dealt with car jacking and god knows what else but the release of videos like these is shaking the nation to its core. Some people think these videos are propaganda tools against our religion. I ask them today is this our religion?

What drives men to slaughter their fellow men like cattle? In the name of a religion which does not condole the killing of even an ant? What makes these men do what they do? No one has answers to this, I myself saw this video in the morning today and since then have been aghast, I really do not know how to react. It is so gruesome I could only watch part of it before I had to shut down, its as if the fabric of my own sanity threatens to collapses on me like a tent with no support.

I would like to appeal to our media to show the truth, I would like to appeal to those concerned to do something about this. I would like to appeal to my fellow citizens to rise up against these militants as today we are watching others being murdered while tomorrow may bring us to the same spot.

I have taken the link of the video as there was no way to certify the age of the people viewing it, however I would urge each and every one of you to search and view it on the internet so that you can see with your own eyes what is what.

IPL fumbles at kickoff

Lalit Modi looked quite upbeat as he made all the captains in the IPL franchise sign off on a wall of sportsmanship in the opening ceremony of the IPL’s second season in Cape town, South Africa. However there was a remarkable difference in the first 2 matches played in last years T20 extravaganza and this one.

The first was off course the atmosphere, no matter how good the facilities may be in S.A they cannot replace the gladiator like feel the cricketers went through last year when they emerged before thousands of roaring, dancing fans to stride to the middle. In short the games had no charisma so far. They were like a packet of salted chips in comparison to a plate of spicey gol gappas or  mixed chat for the fans.

Both opening matches were to me bowler dominated affairs with the ball zipping around under the lights and making things very difficult for batsmen. If this is how the rest of the tournament is going to fare then its going to fail big time. Why? well because the entire thrill of T20 cricket is fans dancing and commentators screaming “its raining sixes”

Without the batsmen being able to T off like they did in India what is going to make sure the crowds limited as they are stay in place? If I want to watch a bowl fest I would go to a test match in England ya know? Plus the majority of subcontinental fans like their heros to be hitting balls out of the park, not playing fine cricket shots. So the sponsers will be nervous as to maintaining their tv ratings as well right now.

Thirdly although the tournament has been trasnplanted in South Africa the entire Indian feel of it is gone. Obviously bollywood stars dancing in the opening ceremony would not have made it “worth watching” for the S.A crowd but to retain not a single Indian element in the ceremony shows what? That this is no longer an Indian Premiere League but more of an International one, so I cannot even understand why its called Indian? Perhaps it is because the teams are still named after indian cities? That can change by the next years tournament too ya know.

The fact that a lot of international stars are not playing this time around has also taken away some of the luster, Sohail tanveer the highest wicket taker of last year is not there, Hussey and Symonds and Brett Lee are not attending either, so although English stars have been put into their places the results can not be the same as the gap in performence will stay in place.

In short if last years IPL started off with a bang this one seemed to have piffed out of existance even before it could take off. I hope things improve as the tournament goes on but with sparse crowds, bowlers advantage and the flavor gone hope is dim. I still maintain that even with rainy problems England would have been a better venue for this event to be shifted to. Now its upto Modi and co to prove me wrong.

Switch to our mobile site